Expert Witness
DHP has experience providing expert witness services. We provide an unbiased evaluation and opinion
based on the data. We can provide expert witness services in the areas of:
- Reverse osmosis & nanofiltration
- Design
- Operation
- Chemical cleaning
- Other areas
- Other high-tech water treatment technologies
- Helping you determine if a lawsuit is viable
- Helping you win a lawsuit brought against you
- Helping you win a lawsuit you have initiated
DETERMINE IF A LAWSUIT IS JUSTIFIED
Cleaning Chemical Caused Destruction of Membrane?
A complete set of RO elements was destroyed during a chemical cleaning at a client's facility. Upon
investigation, it was found that the cleaning chemical formulation had been changed. The client felt that
the destruction of membrane was due to the change. The client hired DHP to evaluate the data and
determine if a lawsuit was justified.
After reviewing the operating and cleaning data, DHP determined that a lawsuit was not justified. A
different RO unit had been cleaned with the same formulation with good results. It was determined that
operator error, likely overheating of the cleaning solution at high pH, had caused the damage. This saved
the company from pursuing a lawsuit which would have ended up being expensive, time-consuming and
embarrassing. They would have lost!
FOR THE DEFENDANT
Evaluate the Poor Performance of a Seawater RO System
There was a lawsuit against a client seeking several million dollars for damages allegedly caused by the
poor performance of a seawater RO system purchased from the client. DHP was hired to review the data,
conduct an on-site evaluation of the equipment and provide a report on the outcome of the investigation.
DHP's evaluation and report showed that the Plaintiff had clearly not followed recommendations for proper
pretreatment, had pumped sand into the system, had removed the cartridge prefilters when the sand plugged
them up, then pumped sand into the high pressure pump and RO unit, plus there were a multitude of other
operational errors. The lawsuit was settled for significantly less than the cost of continuing the
defense. Sometimes it makes economic sense to settle if it's unlikely you can recover the money spent on
defense if you win.
FOR THE PLAINTIFF
Evaluate the Poor Performance of an RO System
A client had purchased a large RO system. The RO system did not meet performance guarantees. The client
sued the company that had sold the RO system. The client hired DHP to evaluate the data and provide a
report. This was a complex situation that required considerable research including a lot of technical
services (autopsies, cleaning evaluation, etc.) as well as DHP obtaining services from other expert
sources. The case was settled with several million dollars paid to the client.